I Love Peanut Butter Cookies

It started when he said he loved the peanut butter cookies from Subway, and incidentally, I do too. In fact, I love anything with peanut butter.

So off I went in search for a recipe for the soft, chewy Subway peanut butter cookie.

I made a batch that was enough for him to bring a box to the office to munch on when he feels like it, and for me to share with the colleagues. There's another box sitting in our kitchen.

I added some butterscotch chips which was so delish but I just can't seem to get the soft, chewy texture. It turns out pretty crunchy like how cookies normally do. Anybody knows why?